yield() and sched_yield() syscalls. Every scheduler has its own way
to relinquish cpu, the ULE and CORE schedulers have two internal run-
queues, a timesharing thread which calls yield() syscall should be
moved to inactive queue.
I picked it up again. The scheduler is forked from ULE, but the
algorithm to detect an interactive process is almost completely
different with ULE, it comes from Linux paper "Understanding the
Linux 2.6.8.1 CPU Scheduler", although I still use same word
"score" as a priority boost in ULE scheduler.
Briefly, the scheduler has following characteristic:
1. Timesharing process's nice value is seriously respected,
timeslice and interaction detecting algorithm are based
on nice value.
2. per-cpu scheduling queue and load balancing.
3. O(1) scheduling.
4. Some cpu affinity code in wakeup path.
5. Support POSIX SCHED_FIFO and SCHED_RR.
Unlike scheduler 4BSD and ULE which using fuzzy RQ_PPQ, the scheduler
uses 256 priority queues. Unlike ULE which using pull and push, the
scheduelr uses pull method, the main reason is to let relative idle
cpu do the work, but current the whole scheduler is protected by the
big sched_lock, so the benefit is not visible, it really can be worse
than nothing because all other cpu are locked out when we are doing
balancing work, which the 4BSD scheduelr does not have this problem.
The scheduler does not support hyperthreading very well, in fact,
the scheduler does not make the difference between physical CPU and
logical CPU, this should be improved in feature. The scheduler has
priority inversion problem on MP machine, it is not good for
realtime scheduling, it can cause realtime process starving.
As a result, it seems the MySQL super-smack runs better on my
Pentium-D machine when using libthr, despite on UP or SMP kernel.
a thread holding critical resource, e.g mutex or other implicit
synchronous flags. Give thread which exceeds nice threshold a minimum
time slice.
PR: kern/86087
as this happens via thread_switchout(). I don't particularly like the
structure of the code here. We twice call out to thread code when
a thread is voluntarily switching. Once to thread_switchout() and once
to slot_fill(), while sched_4BSD does even more work which is redundant
to select another thread to use our remaining slice. This should be
simplified in the future, but for now I'm only going to fix the bug not
the bad design.
slot for us. Previously, we would take two slots on every preempt, and
setrunqueue() would fix it up for us in the non threaded case. The
threaded case was simply broken.
- Clean up flags, prototypes, comments.
schedulers a bit to ensure more correct handling of priorities and fewer
priority inversions:
- Add two functions to the sched(9) API to handle priority lending:
sched_lend_prio() and sched_unlend_prio(). The turnstile code uses these
functions to ask the scheduler to lend a thread a set priority and to
tell the scheduler when it thinks it is ok for a thread to stop borrowing
priority. The unlend case is slightly complex in that the turnstile code
tells the scheduler what the minimum priority of the thread needs to be
to satisfy the requirements of any other threads blocked on locks owned
by the thread in question. The scheduler then decides where the thread
can go back to normal mode (if it's normal priority is high enough to
satisfy the pending lock requests) or it it should continue to use the
priority specified to the sched_unlend_prio() call. This involves adding
a new per-thread flag TDF_BORROWING that replaces the ULE-only kse flag
for priority elevation.
- Schedulers now refuse to lower the priority of a thread that is currently
borrowing another therad's priority.
- If a scheduler changes the priority of a thread that is currently sitting
on a turnstile, it will call a new function turnstile_adjust() to inform
the turnstile code of the change. This function resorts the thread on
the priority list of the turnstile if needed, and if the thread ends up
at the head of the list (due to having the highest priority) and its
priority was raised, then it will propagate that new priority to the
owner of the lock it is blocked on.
Some additional fixes specific to the 4BSD scheduler include:
- Common code for updating the priority of a thread when the user priority
of its associated kse group has been consolidated in a new static
function resetpriority_thread(). One change to this function is that
it will now only adjust the priority of a thread if it already has a
time sharing priority, thus preserving any boosts from a tsleep() until
the thread returns to userland. Also, resetpriority() no longer calls
maybe_resched() on each thread in the group. Instead, the code calling
resetpriority() is responsible for calling resetpriority_thread() on
any threads that need to be updated.
- schedcpu() now uses resetpriority_thread() instead of just calling
sched_prio() directly after it updates a kse group's user priority.
- sched_clock() now uses resetpriority_thread() rather than writing
directly to td_priority.
- sched_nice() now updates all the priorities of the threads after the
group priority has been adjusted.
Discussed with: bde
Reviewed by: ups, jeffr
Tested on: 4bsd, ule
Tested on: i386, alpha, sparc64
- Remove the sched_add wrapper that used sched_add_internal() as a backend.
Its only purpose was to interpret one flag and turn it into an int. Do
the right thing and interpret the flag in sched_add() instead.
- Pass the flag argument to sched_add() to kseq_runq_add() so that we can
get the SRQ_PREEMPT optimization too.
- Add a KEF_INTERNAL flag. If KEF_INTERNAL is set we don't adjust the SLOT
counts, otherwise the slot counts are adjusted as soon as we enter
sched_add() or sched_rem() rather than when the thread is actually placed
on the run queue. This greatly simplifies the handling of slots.
- Remove the explicit prevention of migration for ithreads on non-x86
platforms. This was never shown to have any real benefit.
- Remove the unused class argument to KSE_CAN_MIGRATE().
- Add ktr points for thread migration events.
- Fix a long standing bug on platforms which don't initialize the cpu
topology. The ksg_maxid variable was never correctly set on these
platforms which caused the long term load balancer to never inspect
more than the first group or processor.
- Fix another bug which prevented the long term load balancer from working
properly. If stathz != hz we can't expect sched_clock() to be called
on the exact tick count that we're anticipating.
- Rearrange sched_switch() a bit to reduce indentation levels.
nice of 0. Doing so can cause an infinite loop because they should be
running, but a nice -20 process could prevent them from doing so.
- Add a new flag KEF_PRIOELEV to flag a thread that has had its priority
elevated due to priority propagation. If a thread has had its priority
elevated, we assume that it must go on the current queue and it must
get a slice.
- In sched_userret() if our priority was elevated and we shouldn't have
a timeslice, yield here until we should.
Found/Tested by: glebius
outside of the nice threshold due to a recently awoken thread with a
lower nice value. This further reduces the amount of time a positively
niced thread gets while running in conjunction with a workload that has
many short sleeps (ie buildworld).
check for TD_ON_RUNQ() no longer means the thread is really on a run-
queue. I suspect this state should be re-evaluated as it must mean
something else now. This fixes ULE+KSE+PREEMPTION on UP x86.
fully initialed when the pmap layer tries to call sched_pini() early in the
boot and results in an quick panic. Use ke_pinned instead as was originally
done with Tor's patch.
Approved by: julian
scheduler specific extension to it. Put it in the extension as
the implimentation details of how the pinning is done needn't be visible
outside the scheduler.
Submitted by: tegge (of course!) (with changes)
MFC after: 3 days
but with slightly cleaned up interfaces.
The KSE structure has become the same as the "per thread scheduler
private data" structure. In order to not make the diffs too great
one is #defined as the other at this time.
The KSE (or td_sched) structure is now allocated per thread and has no
allocation code of its own.
Concurrency for a KSEGRP is now kept track of via a simple pair of counters
rather than using KSE structures as tokens.
Since the KSE structure is different in each scheduler, kern_switch.c
is now included at the end of each scheduler. Nothing outside the
scheduler knows the contents of the KSE (aka td_sched) structure.
The fields in the ksegrp structure that are to do with the scheduler's
queueing mechanisms are now moved to the kg_sched structure.
(per ksegrp scheduler private data structure). In other words how the
scheduler queues and keeps track of threads is no-one's business except
the scheduler's. This should allow people to write experimental
schedulers with completely different internal structuring.
A scheduler call sched_set_concurrency(kg, N) has been added that
notifies teh scheduler that no more than N threads from that ksegrp
should be allowed to be on concurrently scheduled. This is also
used to enforce 'fainess' at this time so that a ksegrp with
10000 threads can not swamp a the run queue and force out a process
with 1 thread, since the current code will not set the concurrency above
NCPU, and both schedulers will not allow more than that many
onto the system run queue at a time. Each scheduler should eventualy develop
their own methods to do this now that they are effectively separated.
Rejig libthr's kernel interface to follow the same code paths as
linkse for scope system threads. This has slightly hurt libthr's performance
but I will work to recover as much of it as I can.
Thread exit code has been cleaned up greatly.
exit and exec code now transitions a process back to
'standard non-threaded mode' before taking the next step.
Reviewed by: scottl, peter
MFC after: 1 week
FULL_PREEMPTION is defined. Add a runtime warning to ULE if PREEMPTION is
enabled (code inspired by the PREEMPTION warning in kern_switch.c). This
is a possible MT5 candidate.
preemption and/or the rev 1.79 kern_switch.c change that was backed out.
The thread was being assigned to a runq without adding in the load, which
would cause the counter to hit -1.
migration. Use this in sched_prio() and sched_switch() to stop us from
migrating threads that are in short term sleeps or are runnable. These
extra migrations were added in the patches to support KSE.
- Only set NEEDRESCHED if the thread we're adding in sched_add() is a
lower priority and is being placed on the current queue.
- Fix some minor whitespace problems.
contributed to the transferable load count. This prevents any potential
problems with sched_pin() being used around calls to setrunqueue().
- Change the sched_add() load balancing algorithm to try to migrate on
wakeup. This attempts to place threads that communicate with each other
on the same CPU.
- Don't clear the idle counts in kseq_transfer(), let the cpus do that when
they call sched_add() from kseq_assign().
- Correct a few out of date comments.
- Make sure the ke_cpu field is correct when we preempt.
- Call kseq_assign() from sched_clock() to catch any assignments that were
done without IPI. Presently all assignments are done with an IPI, but I'm
trying a patch that limits that.
- Don't migrate a thread if it is still runnable in sched_add(). Previously,
this could only happen for KSE threads, but due to changes to
sched_switch() all threads went through this path.
- Remove some code that was added with preemption but is not necessary.
specify "us" as the thread not the process/ksegrp/kse.
You can always find the others from the thread but the converse is not true.
Theorotically this would lead to runtime being allocated to the wrong
entity in some cases though it is not clear how often this actually happenned.
(would only affect threaded processes and would probably be pretty benign,
but it WAS a bug..)
Reviewed by: peter
since they are only accessed by curthread and thus do not need any
locking.
- Move pr_addr and pr_ticks out of struct uprof (which is per-process)
and directly into struct thread as td_profil_addr and td_profil_ticks
as these variables are really per-thread. (They are used to defer an
addupc_intr() that was too "hard" until ast()).
